Full Moon Pizzeria

Expect to order at the counter, as there's no table service, and cash is preferred for speed. The crispy thin crust and perfectly balanced sauce have earned rave reviews, although wait times can be inconsistent during rush hours. “Best slice in the Bronx, sauce so good it ruins other pizzas for you,” one customer exclaims. With a plain cheese slice at $3.50 and a pepperoni pie at $22, the prices are reasonable. Open daily from 11am to 10pm, Full Moon Pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Bronx pizza. Go here if you want to taste the legacy of Italian pizza-making in a no-frills setting.

Zero Otto Nove

This spot channels the flavors of southern Italy, elevating local pizza beyond the usual slice. Reservations are advised, and there are no substitutions on specials, but cards are accepted. “Neapolitan perfection right on Arthur Ave, crust like Naples,” praises one satisfied diner. The Margherita pizza is priced at $18, while the prosciutto-topped pie goes for $24. Open Tuesday to Sunday from noon to 10pm, Zero Otto Nove is where you go for a taste of Naples in the Bronx. If you're seeking a slice of Italy with a touch of elegance, this is your destination.

Catania’s Pizzeria & Cafe

Grab slices at the counter or sit down for a meal, with every topping imaginable available. Both cash and cards are accepted. “Sauce and cheese ratio is chef's kiss, don't judge the outside,” says one enthusiastic reviewer. The Neapolitan pie is $20, while the Sicilian square is $25. Open daily from 11am to 11pm, Catania’s Pizzeria & Cafe is a must for those who appreciate the perfect balance of flavors. Visit here for a slice that embodies the heart of Italian pizza-making.

Mario’s Pizzeria & Italian Cuisine

Order at the counter, and don't expect fuss over seating. Cash is preferred to speed things up. “Old school Bronx pie, family secret sauce,” is how one local describes it. The cheese pie costs $21, and a pepperoni slice is $4. Open daily from 11am to 10pm, Mario’s is the place for those who appreciate tradition in their pizza. Head here if you want to taste a piece of Bronx history with every bite.

Famosa Pizza

Slices to go are standard, with no seating loitering allowed. “Greasy NY slice done right,” claims a satisfied customer. A plain slice is $3, and the white pizza is $18. Open daily from noon to 10pm, Famosa Pizza is the go-to for those who love a classic, greasy New York slice. Stop by for a no-nonsense pizza experience.

Ivana's Pizzeria & Restaurant

The full menu goes beyond pizza, with counter pay as the norm. “Stuffed slices that satisfy,” says one happy customer. The calzone is $12, and the grandma slice is $4.50. Open daily for lunch to late, Ivana's is for those who want a unique twist on traditional pizza. Head here for a satisfying, stuffed slice experience.

Joe's Little Italy Pizzeria

Cash only for orders under $10. “Tangy sauce hits the spot,” one customer notes. The pepperoni slice is $3.75, and a large pie is $20. Open daily from 11am to 10pm, Joe's Little Italy Pizzeria is where you go for a quick, tangy slice. Stop by for a taste of Little Italy's classic pizza.

For the best experience, visit Full Moon or Catania mid-afternoon between 2-4pm to avoid the lunch rush. Start with a plain cheese slice to test the crust, then move on to pepperoni. While all places accept cards, using cash can help you avoid $1 fees at counters. Take the D train to the 183rd Street station, which is a 5-minute walk to the Arthur Avenue core. Avoid Pugsley’s on 191st as it's overrated and outside Belmont proper. Street parking is scarce, so consider using garages off Fordham Road.