Overview

Empire Cake, located at 450 6th Avenue in Greenwich Village, is a bakery that combines classic American treats with a gourmet twist. Opened in early 2025 as the second location of an independent New York bakery brand, it offers a spacious setting for enjoying custom-designed cakes, cupcakes, and cookies. This spot serves those seeking more than a quick pastry, providing a venue for events and celebrations with its expanded seating and retail section. With a price range of $$, it's accessible for those looking to indulge in high-quality desserts.

The bakery has earned a Google rating of 4.7 from 132 reviews and a Yelp rating of 4.2 from 736 reviews. These scores reflect its reputation for quality and consistency. Customers rave about the generous portions of cake slices, priced at $15 each, and the creative reimagining of supermarket snack cakes. Empire Cake stands out in a crowded dessert market by offering both sit-down space and a focus on event-scale custom cakes, drawing in locals and visitors alike.

The Neighborhood

Greenwich Village, a historic and vibrant area in Manhattan, is known for its mix of older businesses and newer concepts. Empire Cake fits into this eclectic fabric by providing a large, polished bakery space that caters to both everyday customers and event clients. The neighborhood is home to a diverse population, including residents of The Villager apartment building, where the bakery is located.

Nearby, Jefferson Market Garden and the Jefferson Market Library are key landmarks that draw steady foot traffic. The streets are bustling with locals heading to nearby restaurants and bars on Bleecker Street and 7th Avenue South. This section of Sixth Avenue is less tourist-heavy, making Empire Cake a neighborhood staple rather than a tourist destination.

The Vibe

Empire Cake offers a spacious and inviting atmosphere with 6,700 square feet split between street and basement levels. The wide, bright street-level counter area includes an expanded seating section and retail shelving. This setup makes it more of a café-bakery hybrid than a simple takeout counter. The bakery accepts card payments and partners with Grubhub for delivery, ensuring convenience for all customers.

The service is efficient and friendly, with staff known for their helpfulness and attention to detail. Regulars appreciate the welcoming environment, while first-time visitors can expect prompt service and knowledgeable recommendations. The bakery's setup encourages both quick stops and leisurely visits, making it a versatile choice for various occasions.

What to Order

The standout item at Empire Cake is the cake slice, with options like Red Velvet, Brooklyn Blackout, and Carrot, each priced at $15. These slices are larger than typical diner portions, offering a full layer-cake experience. The texture is moist, and the flavors are rich, making them a must-try for dessert lovers.

In addition to cake slices, the bakery offers cupcakes modeled on childhood snacks, priced at $5–$6 each. Cookies and smaller pastries are available for around $4.00, providing budget-friendly options. A full meal, including a cake slice and a coffee drink, typically costs $19–$21. For those celebrating, custom cakes are available, with prices starting around $65 for standard designs.

Who It's For

Empire Cake is ideal for dessert enthusiasts looking for a sit-down café experience or those planning special events. It's perfect for a leisurely afternoon with a latte and a slice of cake or a more elaborate custom cake order for a celebration.

However, if you're seeking a quick, budget-friendly snack, this might not be the best fit. The bakery's focus on gourmet offerings and event-scale cakes means it's more suited for those willing to spend a bit more. For convenience, delivery is available through Grubhub, making it accessible for those who prefer to enjoy their treats at home.

Getting There

Empire Cake is easily accessible via public transit. The nearest subway station is West 4th Street, served by the A, C, E, B, D, F, and M lines, and it's approximately a 10-minute walk from the bakery. Several bus routes also pass nearby, providing additional options for reaching the location.

For those driving, street parking can be challenging in this busy area. Nearby parking lots offer alternatives, but given the convenience of public transit, driving may not be the most efficient choice. Alternate side parking rules apply, so be mindful of restrictions.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of Empire Cake, you'll find the Jefferson Market Garden and the Jefferson Market Library, both located at 6th Avenue and West 10th Street. These landmarks are popular with locals and add to the area's charm.

Empire Cake fits seamlessly into a day spent exploring Greenwich Village. Visitors to the library or garden can easily stop by for a treat, while those shopping or dining on Bleecker Street can enjoy a sweet finish to their outing. The bakery's location makes it a convenient stop for anyone already in the neighborhood.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit Empire Cake is during weekday mornings before noon, when the bakery is less crowded, and you can enjoy a leisurely experience. The spacious seating area allows for a relaxed visit, whether you're there for a coffee or a detailed cake consultation.

Avoid visiting on weekend afternoons, as this is when the bakery tends to be busiest, with longer wait times and limited seating availability. The bakery's hours are generous, staying open until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, providing flexibility for evening visits.

The Reality Check

Some reviewers note that the prices at Empire Cake can be on the higher side, especially for casual visits. While the quality justifies the cost for many, those on a tight budget might find it less appealing.

Additionally, the focus on gourmet and custom cakes means that those seeking simple, everyday pastries might be disappointed. This is not the place for a quick, cheap snack; it's a destination for high-quality desserts and special occasions.

The Verdict

Empire Cake's City Hacked Rating of Platinum (Score: 91) reflects its strong reputation and quality offerings. The bakery's focus on custom cakes and gourmet desserts, combined with its spacious and inviting atmosphere, makes it a standout choice in Greenwich Village.

Visit Empire Cake for a special treat or event planning, but be prepared for premium pricing. It's a destination for dessert lovers who appreciate quality and creativity. For a memorable dessert experience in Greenwich Village, Empire Cake delivers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the nearest subway lines to Empire Cake?
A: The nearest subway lines are the A, C, E, B, D, F, and M at West 4th Street.

Q: Is there parking available near Empire Cake?
A: Street parking is limited, but nearby parking lots offer alternatives. Be mindful of alternate side rules.

Q: How much does a typical visit to Empire Cake cost?
A: Expect to spend $19–$21 for a cake slice and coffee, or $10–$12 for a cupcake and coffee.

Q: Can I make a reservation at Empire Cake?
A: Reservations are not required for walk-ins, but appointments are recommended for custom cake consultations.

Q: Does Empire Cake offer delivery?
A: Yes, Empire Cake offers delivery through Grubhub, making it convenient for enjoying treats at home.