Overview

Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar, located at 551 5th Ave in Midtown Manhattan, is a flagship venue for the Tommy Bahama lifestyle brand. This spot combines retail and dining, offering an island-inspired escape in the heart of New York City. With a price range of $$$, it caters to Midtown office workers, tourists, and pre-theater diners seeking a tropical twist on Fifth Avenue.

Opened in late 2012, this venue is not just about shopping; it’s about extending the brand experience into food and drink. The space is part of a three-level flagship that includes a retail floor, the restaurant, and the Marlin Bar. The Google rating of 4.5 from 1,264 reviews and a Yelp score of 4.1 from 717 reviews reflect its consistent appeal. The ambiance and friendly staff are frequently highlighted by patrons, setting it apart from other Midtown options.

The Neighborhood

Midtown Manhattan is a bustling hub of commerce and tourism, with Fifth Avenue serving as a major artery. The area is characterized by its mix of high-end retail, corporate offices, and iconic landmarks. Tommy Bahama fits seamlessly into this environment, offering a respite for shoppers and office workers alike.

Nearby, Bryant Park and the New York Public Library provide cultural landmarks within walking distance. The foot traffic is a blend of tourists exploring the city and locals navigating their daily routines. This venue attracts those looking for a reliable stop amidst Midtown's busy streets, offering a blend of retail therapy and dining.

The Vibe

Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar offers a relaxed atmosphere, with no cover charge and a focus on comfort. The space is described as beautiful and well-maintained, with live music from 4:30 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. most evenings. Reservations are recommended, but walk-ins are welcome during non-peak hours.

Service is a standout feature, with reviewers praising the friendly and welcoming staff. The owner is noted for his personable approach, contributing to a positive experience. Regulars appreciate the consistent warmth and hospitality, making first-time visitors feel at ease from the moment they enter.

What to Drink

The Mai Tai, priced between $14 and $16, is a must-try. This rum-heavy cocktail is a favorite among patrons for its tropical flair. The Pineapple Paradiso, a vodka-based drink at a similar price point, offers a refreshing pineapple twist.

For those looking to explore more, the Frozen Mai Tai provides a vacation-style option. The World Famous Coconut Shrimp, priced around $16–$18, pairs well with these drinks. A typical night out, including a cocktail, appetizer, and entree, ranges from $60 to $80 per person, making it a mid-tier Midtown dining experience.

Who It's For

This venue is ideal for those seeking a laid-back dining experience with a touch of island flair. It's perfect for business lunches, pre-theater dinners, or a casual night out with friends.

However, if you're looking for a late-night party scene, this isn't the place. It closes by 9 p.m. on weekdays and 8 p.m. on Saturdays, catering more to those who prefer an early evening outing.

Getting There

Tommy Bahama is easily accessible via public transit. The nearest subway stations are 5th Ave-Bryant Park (B, D, F, M) and Grand Central (4, 5, 6, 7, S), both within a 5–7 minute walk.

Driving in Midtown can be challenging due to traffic and limited parking. Street parking is scarce, but nearby garages offer paid options. Given the excellent transit access, it's advisable to use public transportation.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance, you'll find Bryant Park and the New York Public Library, both offering cultural and leisure activities. Grand Central Terminal is also nearby, providing a historic and architectural landmark.

This venue is a convenient stop for those exploring Midtown's attractions. Whether you're shopping on Fifth Avenue or visiting nearby landmarks, Tommy Bahama offers a reliable dining option to complement your itinerary.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit is during the week for lunch or early dinner. Arriving between 3 p.m. and 6 p.m. allows you to enjoy happy hour specials and live music without the evening rush.

Avoid weekends if you dislike crowds, as Saturdays can be busy with tourists. The venue is closed on Sundays, so plan your visit accordingly to avoid disappointment.

The Reality Check

While the venue receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, it may not satisfy those seeking high-energy nightlife. Its early closing hours and focus on dining over drinking limit its appeal for night owls.

This is not a destination for cutting-edge cocktails or a club atmosphere. If you're looking for a lively bar scene, you may leave unsatisfied. Instead, expect a calm, enjoyable dining experience.

The Verdict

Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar earns its City Hacked Gold rating with a score of 85 due to its consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere. The combination of positive reviews and its strategic Midtown location make it a reliable choice for those seeking a pleasant dining experience.

Visit for the tropical drinks and friendly service, but skip it if you're after a late-night adventure. For a taste of island life in Midtown, this venue delivers a dependable escape.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is there a cover charge?
A: No, there is no cover charge at Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar.

Q: What are the happy hour times?
A: Happy hour runs from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday.

Q: Can I walk in without a reservation?
A: Yes, walk-ins are welcome, but reservations are recommended during peak times.

Q: How close is the nearest subway station?
A: The 5th Ave-Bryant Park station is about a 5-minute walk away.

Q: What is the dress code?
A: The dress code is casual, fitting the relaxed island theme of the venue.