Overview

DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake, located at 977 Victory Blvd in Staten Island, is a family-driven Italian eatery established in 2016. Known for its nearly century-old family recipe, the restaurant focuses on artisan-level specialty pies and Italian dishes. It's a go-to spot for locals seeking quality Italian food without the Manhattan price tag, with a price range that sits comfortably at $$.

The restaurant boasts a Google rating of 4.6 from 144 reviews and a Yelp rating of 4.6 from an impressive 3,845 reviews. The emphasis on house-made dough and bread sets it apart from typical pizzerias. With its late-night hours extending to 11 PM on weekends, it caters to both dinner crowds and late-night diners.

The Neighborhood

Silver Lake, Staten Island, is a residential area with a mix of families and young professionals. The restaurant's location on Victory Blvd makes it a convenient dinner stop for those commuting through this major corridor. It's a neighborhood where residents appreciate a good meal without venturing far from home.

Nearby, you'll find Silver Lake Park, a popular spot for locals seeking outdoor activities. The area is characterized by steady foot traffic, especially from those visiting the park or commuting along Victory Blvd. The restaurant fits seamlessly into this community, serving as a reliable dining option for both residents and passersby.

The Vibe

DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake offers a moderate noise level, making it suitable for both casual dinners and group gatherings. The space is designed to accommodate diners comfortably, with a layout that avoids the cramped feel of many NYC eateries. It accepts both cash and cards, and offers delivery through platforms like Grubhub and Seamless.

Service is consistently praised, with staff known for their attentiveness and friendliness. Regulars appreciate the warm, familial atmosphere, while first-timers often comment on the welcoming nature of the team. The staff's efficiency ensures a smooth dining experience, even during peak hours.

What to Order

The standout dish is the house specialty pie, crafted with the family's traditional dough recipe. Its crispy crust and perfectly balanced toppings make it a must-order. Another recommendation is the homemade bread, which complements any meal with its fresh, aromatic quality.

For those exploring the menu further, the pasta dishes are a hit, offering authentic Italian flavors. While exact prices aren't listed, the menu's range ensures there's something for everyone. Expect to spend around $20–$30 per person for a full meal, including a drink.

Who It's For

DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake is ideal for families seeking a reliable dinner spot, couples on a casual date night, and anyone craving late-night Italian fare. Its welcoming environment and quality dishes make it a favorite among neighborhood regulars.

However, if you're seeking a quick grab-and-go meal, this might not be the place. The focus here is on a relaxed dining experience. For those who prefer delivery, options are available through major platforms, making it convenient for a cozy night in.

Getting There

While specific subway lines aren't detailed, the restaurant is accessible via Staten Island's bus routes. The Victory Blvd location is well-connected, making it easy for locals and visitors to reach.

Driving is an option, with street parking available, though it can be competitive. For those unfamiliar with Staten Island's parking rules, it's advisable to check for alternate side regulations to avoid fines.

Nearby Attractions

Silver Lake Park is just a short walk away, offering a scenic escape for those looking to enjoy nature before or after their meal. The park is a community hub, drawing families and fitness enthusiasts alike.

For visitors exploring Staten Island, DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake serves as a culinary highlight. It's a great addition to a day spent in the area, whether you're visiting the park or exploring local shops.

Best Time to Visit

Weekdays before 6 PM are ideal for a quieter dining experience, avoiding the dinner rush. For late-night cravings, visiting after 9 PM on weekends ensures you enjoy the extended hours without the crowd.

Avoid visiting on Tuesdays, as the restaurant is closed. Weekend evenings can get busy, so reservations are recommended if you plan to dine during peak hours.

The Reality Check

Some reviewers mention occasional wait times during peak hours, but these are generally offset by the quality of the food and service. It's advisable to plan ahead if you're visiting during busy periods.

While the restaurant excels in its core offerings, those expecting a wide variety of dishes might be disappointed. The focus is on quality over quantity, catering to those who appreciate traditional Italian fare.

The Verdict

DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake earns its City Hacked Platinum rating with a score of 93, reflecting its strong community presence and consistent quality. The score highlights its status as a top choice for Italian cuisine in Staten Island.

Visit for the artisan pies and welcoming atmosphere, but skip if you're in a rush. It's a place to savor, not to rush through. For a taste of family tradition, this is the spot.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the restaurant's hours?
A: DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake is open daily except Tuesday, with extended hours until 11 PM on weekends.

Q: Is there parking available?
A: Street parking is available, but it can be competitive. Check for alternate side rules.

Q: Can I make a reservation?
A: Yes, reservations are recommended, especially during peak dinner hours on weekends.

Q: Does the restaurant offer delivery?
A: Yes, delivery is available through Grubhub and Seamless.

Q: What is the price range for a meal?
A: Expect to spend around $20–$30 per person for a full meal, including a drink.