Overview

Paradise Island, located at 225 Ellis Street in Tottenville, Staten Island, is a seafood restaurant and Tiki bar that has carved out a niche as a hybrid dining and nightlife venue. With a price range of $$, it caters to locals seeking both a meal and a party atmosphere. The restaurant operates independently, focusing on American bar food and drinks, and has been around since the mid-2010s. It is not part of a chain, setting it apart from other seafood spots by its dual identity as a restaurant by day and a nightlife destination on weekends.

Food quality is a major draw here. The Chicken Tenders are praised for being “crispy and well-seasoned,” while the Cheeseburger is noted for being “juicy and flavorful.” Paradise Island holds a Google rating of 4 from 238 reviews and a Yelp rating of 3.6 from 48 reviews. This place stands out with its unique blend of dining and entertainment, making it a go-to spot for those looking to enjoy both good food and a lively night out.

The Neighborhood

Tottenville, located at the southern tip of Staten Island, is a low-density, car-centric neighborhood. The area is characterized by a mix of residential streets and industrial corridors. Paradise Island fits into this local fabric by offering a unique dining and nightlife experience that contrasts with the more conventional pizzerias and diners in the area. It serves as a local hotspot for residents who prefer not to travel far for a night out.

The restaurant is situated near Arthur Kill Road and the waterfront industrial corridor, providing a semi-industrial backdrop. Nearby streets like Johnson Avenue and Amboy Road feature a mix of auto shops and small businesses, contributing to the area's eclectic character. Foot traffic is moderate, with locals and those from neighboring areas frequenting the venue, especially on weekends.

The Vibe

The atmosphere at Paradise Island is a blend of dining and entertainment, with a space designed to accommodate both. The noise level is moderate, making it suitable for casual dining and special occasions. The restaurant accepts credit and debit cards and offers delivery and takeout options through platforms like Slice. Reservations are recommended for weekend nights when the venue transforms into a nightlife spot.

Service is generally friendly and accommodating, with staff often going above and beyond to enhance the dining experience. Reviewers frequently mention the staff's kindness and willingness to create memorable experiences, although some have noted slower service during peak hours. First-time visitors can expect a welcoming environment, but should be prepared for potential delays during busy periods.

What to Order

The Chicken Tenders, priced around $12–$16, are a standout dish, known for their crispy texture and generous portion size. Another must-try is the Cheeseburger, which ranges from $13–$16. It's described as juicy and cooked to perfection, offering excellent value for the price. Both dishes are staples that highlight the restaurant's commitment to quality.

For those looking to explore more of the menu, the “Date Night Steak Night Dinner for Two” is a notable option at $95 plus tax. Desserts include the Chocolate Mousse Cake, priced at $6–$8, and the Espresso Affogato, ranging from $7–$9. A typical meal here, including an appetizer, main course, and drink, costs between $30–$45 per person.

Who It's For

Paradise Island is ideal for those seeking a vibrant night out without leaving Staten Island. It's perfect for date nights, group gatherings, and anyone looking to enjoy both a meal and entertainment in one place. The restaurant's late-night hours and Tiki bar atmosphere make it a prime spot for those who enjoy nightlife.

However, it's not the best choice for those seeking a quiet, intimate dining experience or those who are impatient with wait times. The restaurant's delivery and takeout options provide an alternative for those who prefer to enjoy the food without the nightlife scene. For those who enjoy a lively atmosphere, Paradise Island is worth the visit.

Getting There

Reaching Paradise Island by public transit involves taking the Staten Island Railway to the Tottenville station, followed by a short bus ride on the S74 or S78, which stops near Arthur Kill Road. The walk from the bus stop to the restaurant takes about 10 minutes, making it accessible for those relying on public transportation.

Driving is a viable option, given Tottenville's car-friendly nature. Street parking is generally available, though it can be limited during peak hours. Nearby parking lots offer additional options, but it's advisable to arrive early to secure a spot. Given the transit options, driving is convenient but not essential.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of Paradise Island, you'll find the Tottenville Marina, a popular spot for boating enthusiasts, located just a few blocks away. The Conference House Park, a historic site and nature preserve, is also nearby, offering scenic views and walking trails.

For those visiting Tottenville for other reasons, Paradise Island serves as a convenient dining option. Whether you're exploring the local parks or attending events at the marina, the restaurant provides a satisfying meal and a chance to unwind in a lively setting.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit Paradise Island is on weekdays before 6 PM, when the restaurant is less crowded, and service is quicker. This timing allows diners to enjoy the food without the rush of the nightlife crowd, making it ideal for families and those looking for a more relaxed dining experience.

Avoid visiting on Friday and Saturday nights if you're not a fan of crowds. These are the busiest times, with long wait times and a bustling atmosphere. The restaurant stays open until 3 AM on these nights, catering to the nightlife crowd, so plan accordingly if you prefer a quieter visit.

The Reality Check

The most common complaint about Paradise Island is the long wait times during peak hours. Some diners have reported waiting over 30 minutes for their food, which can be frustrating for those expecting quick service. This is a significant consideration for anyone planning to visit during busy periods.

Secondary issues include occasional slow service and cleanliness concerns, particularly in the restrooms. While the dining area is generally well-maintained, the restrooms could benefit from more frequent checks. Those who prioritize quick service and pristine facilities may find these aspects disappointing.

The Verdict

Paradise Island earned its City Hacked Rating of Gold with a score of 82, reflecting its strong community presence and unique blend of dining and nightlife. This score indicates a reliable choice for those seeking a lively experience on Staten Island, supported by positive reviews and consistent quality.

Visit Paradise Island for a memorable night out, especially if you're in the mood for good food and entertainment. However, if you prefer a quiet dining experience or have little patience for wait times, this might not be the best fit. The restaurant's dual identity as a dining and nightlife venue is its defining feature.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the closest public transit options to Paradise Island?
A: The Staten Island Railway to Tottenville station, followed by the S74 or S78 bus, gets you close.

Q: Is parking available near Paradise Island?
A: Yes, street parking is generally available, with additional options in nearby parking lots.

Q: What is the price range for a meal at Paradise Island?
A: Expect to spend $30–$45 per person for a full meal, including drinks.

Q: Do I need a reservation for Paradise Island?
A: Reservations are recommended for weekend nights, especially if you plan to enjoy the nightlife.

Q: Is Paradise Island suitable for family dining?
A: Yes, it's suitable for families, especially during weekdays before the nightlife crowd arrives.