Overview

Pelham Pizza, located at 113 Fifth Avenue in Pelham, New York, has been serving classic New York-style pizza since 1978. Founded by Italian brothers Luigi and Ettore Ruffolo, this family-run establishment has become a staple for locals seeking authentic pizza and Italian-American dishes. With a price range of $-$$, it caters to both budget-conscious diners and those looking for a satisfying meal without breaking the bank.

The restaurant boasts a Google rating of 4.7 from 922 reviews and a Yelp rating of 4.3 from 228 reviews, indicating consistent satisfaction among patrons. Known for its Large Cheese Pizza and Chicken Marsala Rolls, Pelham Pizza stands out for its quality ingredients and traditional recipes. Its reputation as a neighborhood institution is bolstered by its long-standing history and the dedication of the Ruffolo/Mancini family in maintaining its legacy.

The Neighborhood

Pelham Pizza is situated in the Village of Pelham, a small community just north of the Bronx. This area is characterized by its suburban feel, with a mix of residential homes and local businesses lining the streets. The pizzeria fits seamlessly into this setting, serving as a go-to spot for families, commuters, and students looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.

The restaurant is located on Fifth Avenue, a busy commercial strip that serves as Pelham's main street. Within walking distance are the Pelham Metro-North station and other local eateries, making it a convenient stop for those traveling through the area. The foot traffic consists mainly of locals and commuters, providing a steady stream of customers throughout the day.

The Vibe

Pelham Pizza offers a casual dining experience with a focus on dine-in and carryout options. The space is set up for quick service, with a counter for ordering and a few tables for those who wish to eat in. The atmosphere is relaxed and unpretentious, making it a comfortable spot for a casual meal.

Service at Pelham Pizza is efficient and friendly, with staff known for their quick turnaround and welcoming demeanor. Regulars appreciate the consistent quality and speed of service, while newcomers can expect a straightforward and pleasant dining experience. The restaurant's integration with delivery platforms like Grubhub adds to its accessibility, allowing for easy ordering and fast delivery.

What to Order

The Large Cheese Pizza, priced at $22.00, is a must-try for anyone visiting Pelham Pizza. This classic New York-style pie features a thin, foldable crust with just the right amount of mozzarella and tomato sauce. The balance of flavors and textures makes it a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts.

For those looking to explore beyond the basics, the Chicken Marsala Rolls are a popular option. These rolls, filled with chicken and marsala-style mushrooms, offer a savory and satisfying bite. Other menu highlights include the Grandma Pizza and the Broccoli Rabe and Grilled Chicken hero, with prices for these items generally ranging from the low teens to the low twenties. A typical meal here, including a couple of slices and a drink, will cost around $12-$20 per person.

Who It's For

Pelham Pizza is ideal for families, students, and locals seeking a reliable spot for lunch or dinner. Its affordable pricing and casual atmosphere make it a great choice for a quick meal or a relaxed family dinner. The restaurant's late hours, open until midnight on weekdays, also cater to those with late-night cravings.

However, if you're looking for a formal dining experience or a trendy hotspot, this might not be the place for you. The focus here is on good food and friendly service rather than ambiance. For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home, Pelham Pizza's presence on delivery platforms like Grubhub makes it a convenient option.

Getting There

Pelham Pizza is easily accessible via the Metro-North New Haven Line, with the Pelham station just a short walk away. The station provides a convenient transit option for those coming from nearby areas, making it a popular choice for commuters and locals alike.

For those driving, street parking is available along Fifth Avenue and the surrounding streets. However, parking can be limited during peak hours, so it's advisable to plan accordingly. The proximity to the Metro-North station also makes public transit a viable option for visitors.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of Pelham Pizza, you'll find the Pelham Metro-North station and a variety of local shops and eateries. This central location makes it a convenient stop for those exploring the area or commuting through Pelham.

The restaurant's position on Fifth Avenue places it in the heart of Pelham's commercial district, attracting a diverse crowd of locals, commuters, and visitors. Whether you're in town for a day trip or passing through, Pelham Pizza offers a taste of local flavor in a convenient and accessible setting.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit Pelham Pizza is in the late afternoon, between 3:00 PM and 5:00 PM, or later at night after the dinner rush. These times typically see less foot traffic, allowing for a more relaxed dining experience and minimal wait times.

Avoid visiting during the peak dinner hours of 6:30 PM to 8:00 PM, especially on weekends, when the restaurant is busiest. The late-night hours, with the restaurant open until midnight from Monday to Saturday, provide an opportunity for a quieter visit.

The Reality Check

While Pelham Pizza enjoys high ratings, some reviewers note that the space can be cramped during peak hours, leading to longer wait times and limited seating availability. The focus on quick service means that the dining experience may feel rushed for those expecting a leisurely meal.

Additionally, the restaurant's straightforward approach may not appeal to diners seeking a more upscale or innovative dining experience. If you're looking for a trendy spot with a unique menu, you might be disappointed. However, for those who appreciate classic pizza and Italian-American dishes, Pelham Pizza delivers consistently.

The Verdict

Pelham Pizza earns its City Hacked Rating of Platinum with a score of 89, reflecting its strong community presence and consistent quality. The restaurant's long history, family ownership, and dedication to traditional recipes make it a beloved local institution.

For those seeking authentic New York-style pizza in a casual setting, Pelham Pizza is a solid choice. It's best suited for those who value good food and friendly service over ambiance. “Classic pizza, family-run, and always satisfying.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the operating hours of Pelham Pizza?
A: Pelham Pizza is open from 11 AM to 10 PM daily.

Q: Is there parking available near Pelham Pizza?
A: Street parking is available, but it can be limited during peak hours.

Q: Does Pelham Pizza offer delivery?
A: Yes, Pelham Pizza is available for delivery through platforms like Grubhub.

Q: What is the price range for a meal at Pelham Pizza?
A: Meals typically range from $12 to $20 per person, depending on the order.

Q: Can I make reservations at Pelham Pizza?
A: Pelham Pizza operates on a walk-in basis; reservations are not accepted.