Overview

5 Burro Cafe in Forest Hills, Queens, has been serving Mexican classics and Americanized favorites since 1990. Founded by Marla Cornejo, this spot is known for its vibrant atmosphere and late-night margaritas. With a price range of $$, it attracts a diverse crowd, from locals to adventurous diners seeking a casual yet flavorful meal. The Forest Hills location remains a staple, offering dishes like chiles rellenos and surf and turf specials that keep patrons coming back.

The cafe's Google rating of 4.4 from 2,529 reviews and a Yelp rating of 3.6 from 1,627 reviews reflect its popularity. Reviewers praise the generous portions and lively environment, though some note the occasional wait time. The combination of authentic Mexican dishes and hearty American offerings sets it apart from other eateries in the area. The consistent quality and friendly service make it a go-to destination for those exploring Austin Street.

The Neighborhood

Forest Hills in Queens is a residential area with a mix of families and young professionals. 5 Burro Cafe fits seamlessly into this neighborhood, offering a laid-back dining option amidst the busy Austin Street shopping strip. The area is known for its tree-lined streets and historic charm, providing a welcoming backdrop for this long-standing establishment.

Nearby, the Forest Hills Gardens entrance gates lead to private streets, adding to the area's appeal. The foot traffic on Austin Street is a mix of shoppers and locals, creating a lively scene. The proximity to stores like Duane Reade and local boutiques ensures a steady stream of visitors passing by the cafe, making it a convenient stop for those exploring the neighborhood.

The Vibe

5 Burro Cafe is a compact space that fills up quickly, especially on weekends. The dining room is lively, with conversations and laughter echoing off the walls. Open daily from 12 PM to 1 AM, it operates as a walk-in spot, with no reservations. The wait can be long during peak times, but the bustling atmosphere is part of the draw.

Service at 5 Burro Cafe is friendly and efficient, with staff known for their attentiveness. Regulars appreciate the personal touch, while newcomers are welcomed warmly. The staff's ability to manage the busy environment contributes to the overall experience, ensuring that diners leave satisfied and eager to return.

What to Order

The chiles rellenos are a standout, featuring cheese-stuffed peppers battered and fried to perfection. This dish is a must-try for anyone visiting the cafe. The surf and turf specials offer a unique twist, combining seafood and steak in a way that appeals to both traditional and adventurous palates.

For those with a sweet tooth, the apple chimichanga is a delightful dessert option. Fried pastry filled with apple and drizzled in sauce, it's a satisfying end to any meal. While specific prices aren't listed, a typical meal ranges from $20 to $30 per person. The menu's variety ensures there's something for everyone, from classic Mexican dishes to American favorites.

Who It's For

5 Burro Cafe is ideal for groups looking to enjoy a lively night out with friends. The generous margarita pitchers and hearty dishes make it perfect for sharing. It's also a great spot for families seeking a casual dining experience with a mix of flavors to satisfy all tastes.

However, those seeking a quiet, intimate meal might find the bustling environment overwhelming. The cafe's popularity can lead to long waits, especially on weekends. For those who prefer dining at home, delivery options through popular platforms are available, offering a convenient alternative.

Getting There

The Forest Hills–71st Avenue station on the E, F, M, and R lines is the nearest subway stop, just a 3-minute walk east along Austin Street. The Q23 and Q60 buses also stop directly outside the cafe, providing easy access for those using public transit.

Driving to 5 Burro Cafe can be challenging due to limited street parking and alternate side rules. Metered spots are scarce, especially on weekends. Given the convenient transit options, taking the subway or bus is often the more practical choice for visitors.

Nearby Attractions

5 Burro Cafe is located near the bustling Austin Street shopping strip, home to a variety of stores and boutiques. Just a short walk away, the Forest Hills Gardens entrance offers a glimpse into the area's historic architecture and lush greenery.

Visitors to the neighborhood can enjoy a day of shopping and exploration before heading to the cafe for a meal. The combination of local attractions and dining options makes it an appealing destination for both locals and tourists seeking to experience a different side of Queens.

Best Time to Visit

Weekdays before 6 PM are the best times to visit 5 Burro Cafe if you want to avoid the post-work rush. Arriving by noon on Sundays also ensures a lighter crowd, allowing for a more relaxed dining experience.

Avoid peak weekend nights after 9 PM, when tables fill quickly with neighborhood groups. The cafe's late hours, open until 1 AM, make it a popular spot for late-night dining, but also contribute to the longer waits during these times.

The Reality Check

Some reviewers mention the noise level as a common complaint, noting that the lively atmosphere can be overwhelming for those seeking a quieter meal. The wait times during peak hours are another frequent issue, with some diners expressing frustration over the lack of reservations.

Additionally, the space can feel cramped when crowded, which might not suit everyone. Those expecting a more spacious or serene dining experience may leave disappointed. It's a place for those who thrive in energetic environments and enjoy the hustle and bustle of a popular local spot.

The Verdict

5 Burro Cafe's City Hacked Rating of Gold (Score: 80) reflects its strong community presence and consistent quality. The score indicates a reliable choice for those seeking a lively dining experience with flavorful dishes and a welcoming atmosphere.

Visit for the vibrant energy and generous margaritas, but be prepared for a wait during peak times. It's a quintessential Queens spot that captures the essence of Forest Hills dining. For a night of fun and flavor, 5 Burro Cafe is the place to be.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the hours of operation?
A: 5 Burro Cafe is open daily from 12 PM to 1 AM.

Q: Is there parking available nearby?
A: Street parking is limited, but the Q23 and Q60 buses stop directly outside the cafe.

Q: What is the nearest subway station?
A: The Forest Hills–71st Avenue station on the E, F, M, and R lines is a 3-minute walk away.

Q: Are reservations accepted?
A: No, 5 Burro Cafe operates on a walk-in basis only.

Q: What is the typical cost of a meal?
A: Expect to spend between $20 and $30 per person for a full meal.