Overview

Continent Brooklyn, located at 500 Metropolitan Ave in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a Caribbean-Asian fusion restaurant that opened in June 2024. Founded by chef Scotley Innis and Aliya Huey, it brings the flavors of Jamaica to a nightlife-driven dining experience inside Hotel Indigo. The restaurant serves a crowd looking for upscale dining with a twist, offering a unique blend of Caribbean and Asian influences. With a focus on nightlife, it's not your typical neighborhood spot but rather a destination for those seeking a vibrant atmosphere and inventive cuisine.

The restaurant holds a Google rating of 4.2 based on 134 reviews and a similar Yelp rating with 61 reviews. The menu features dishes like whole fried snapper and Jamaican jerk lamb shank, drawing diners who appreciate well-executed, flavorful dishes. The restaurant's strong bar program and late-night hours make it a popular choice for those looking to enjoy a lively night out in Williamsburg. With its unique culinary approach and strategic location, Continent Brooklyn stands out among the many dining options in the area.

The Neighborhood

Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is known for its eclectic mix of residents, from young professionals to artists and long-time locals. Continent Brooklyn fits into this dynamic neighborhood by offering a dining experience that caters to both hotel guests and locals looking for a night out. The area is characterized by its mix of trendy bars, restaurants, and cultural venues, making it a hotspot for nightlife and entertainment.

Located near the Metropolitan Av–Lorimer St subway station, the restaurant benefits from a steady stream of foot traffic. The nearby Brooklyn–Queens Expressway and Williamsburg Bridge ensure that the area is easily accessible by car as well. This part of Williamsburg is bustling with activity, attracting a diverse crowd of visitors and residents who are drawn to its vibrant energy and cultural offerings.

The Vibe

Continent Brooklyn offers a lively dining experience with seating for 110 guests across two dining rooms. The space features two-story windows overlooking a garden, creating an inviting atmosphere. The restaurant's design includes velvet chairs and a stylish interior, setting the stage for a night out rather than a casual meal. Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, to ensure a spot in this popular venue.

Service at Continent Brooklyn is attentive and geared towards creating a memorable experience. The staff is known for being friendly and knowledgeable, guiding guests through the menu and drink options. Regulars appreciate the consistent quality of service, while first-time visitors can expect a warm welcome and helpful recommendations. The presence of live DJs adds to the energetic atmosphere, making it a place to enjoy both food and entertainment.

What to Order

The whole fried snapper, priced between $38 and $55, is a standout dish at Continent Brooklyn. Its crispy skin and red curry sauce make it a must-order for anyone visiting the restaurant. The Jamaican jerk lamb shank is another highlight, offering a tender, slow-braised experience with a rich jerk spice rub. These dishes exemplify the restaurant's commitment to bold flavors and creative presentations.

For those looking to explore more of the menu, the oxtail spring rolls and island-spiced wings are popular choices. While exact prices are not listed, a full meal with a cocktail, appetizer, and main course typically ranges from $70 to $100 per person. This price point reflects the restaurant's upscale positioning and the quality of its offerings.

Who It's For

Continent Brooklyn is ideal for those seeking a lively night out with friends or a date night in Williamsburg. Its upscale atmosphere and inventive menu appeal to diners looking for a unique culinary experience. The restaurant's late-night hours and strong bar program make it a great choice for evening gatherings.

However, those seeking a quiet, casual meal may want to look elsewhere. The lively atmosphere and focus on nightlife mean it's not the best fit for a relaxed dinner. Additionally, the lack of delivery options suggests that it's best suited for on-premise dining rather than takeout.

Getting There

The Metropolitan Av–Lorimer St station, served by the L and G lines, is the closest subway stop to Continent Brooklyn. From the station, it's a short 3–4 minute walk to the restaurant. The B24 and B48 bus routes also run nearby, providing additional transit options for visitors.

For those driving, the restaurant is accessible via the Brooklyn–Queens Expressway and Williamsburg Bridge. Street parking can be challenging, but nearby parking lots offer alternatives. Given the area's transit options, taking public transportation is often the most convenient choice.

Nearby Attractions

Continent Brooklyn is situated near several notable landmarks, including the Williamsburg Bridge and the Brooklyn–Queens Expressway. These landmarks contribute to the area's accessibility and draw both locals and tourists to the neighborhood.

Visitors to Williamsburg often come for its vibrant nightlife and cultural scene. Continent Brooklyn fits seamlessly into this environment, offering a dining experience that complements a day spent exploring the area's shops, galleries, and music venues. It's an ideal stop for those looking to cap off their day with a memorable meal.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit Continent Brooklyn is during the evening hours, particularly on weekends when the restaurant is most lively. Arriving before 8 p.m. ensures a better chance of securing a table without a long wait, especially if you have a reservation.

Avoid visiting during peak dinner hours on Fridays and Saturdays if you dislike crowds. The restaurant tends to be busiest during these times, and the lively atmosphere may not suit those seeking a quiet dining experience. With its late-night hours, it's a great option for night owls looking to enjoy a vibrant scene.

The Reality Check

Some reviewers mention that the restaurant can be quite loud, particularly on weekends when live DJs are present. This may not be ideal for those seeking a quiet dining experience. Additionally, a few diners have noted that the service can be slow during peak hours.

While the restaurant's upscale atmosphere and inventive menu are praised, it's not the best choice for budget-conscious diners. The higher price point reflects the quality and creativity of the dishes, but it may not be suitable for those looking for a more affordable meal.

The Verdict

Continent Brooklyn's City Hacked Rating of Gold (Score: 87) reflects its strong presence in Williamsburg's dining scene. The restaurant's unique blend of Caribbean and Asian influences, combined with its lively atmosphere, make it a standout choice for those seeking a memorable night out. The score indicates a high level of quality and consistency, appealing to diners who value both food and experience.

For those looking to enjoy a vibrant dining experience in Williamsburg, Continent Brooklyn is worth a visit. However, if you prefer a quieter, more casual meal, it may not be the best fit. “For a lively night out, Continent Brooklyn delivers.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the hours of operation for Continent Brooklyn?
A: Continent Brooklyn is open Wednesday to Saturday from 5 p.m. to midnight and Sunday from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m.

Q: Is there a dress code at Continent Brooklyn?
A: While there's no strict dress code, the upscale atmosphere suggests smart casual attire.

Q: Can I make a reservation at Continent Brooklyn?
A: Yes, reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, and can be made through Resy.

Q: What is the nearest subway station to Continent Brooklyn?
A: The nearest subway station is Metropolitan Av–Lorimer St, served by the L and G lines.

Q: Does Continent Brooklyn offer delivery?
A: No, Continent Brooklyn focuses on on-premise dining and does not offer delivery services.