Overview

Della Nonna Gelato, located at 156 Tompkins Ave in Brooklyn, is a neighborhood gelato counter that has been serving artisanal Italian-style gelato since mid-2022. Known for its small-batch production, this spot is perfect for those seeking authentic gelato without the fuss of a sit-down restaurant. With prices ranging from $6.50 for a small cup to $15 for a pint, it caters to both casual visitors and gelato aficionados.

The shop boasts a high Google rating of 4.9 from 65 reviews and a similar Yelp rating from 11 reviews, indicating consistent quality and satisfaction. Regulars rave about the dense, nutty Pistachio and the sweet cream Stracciatella with chocolate shards. The focus on core Italian flavors and smooth texture sets it apart from other dessert options in the area, making it a must-visit for gelato lovers.

The Neighborhood

Della Nonna Gelato is situated in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, a neighborhood known for its rich cultural history and vibrant community life. The area is a mix of long-time residents and newcomers, with a blend of brownstones and local businesses lining the streets. The gelato shop fits right into this local fabric, offering a sweet stop for those exploring the neighborhood.

Nearby, you'll find landmarks like Peaches HotHouse, just two blocks south, and Herbert von King Park, a ten-minute walk north. The foot traffic is a mix of locals and visitors, creating a lively atmosphere. The street is bustling with people heading to nearby cafes, restaurants, and parks, making it an ideal spot for a quick gelato break.

The Vibe

Della Nonna Gelato operates as a compact counter-service shop with a focus on takeaway orders. The interior is minimalist, with a gelato case greeting customers as they enter. Seating is limited to a few stools, so most patrons enjoy their gelato outside. Payment is convenient with a modern POS system, and the shop is active on delivery platforms like Seamless and Grubhub.

Service is straightforward and efficient, with staff ready to help you choose from the rotating flavors. Regulars appreciate the friendly staff and quick service, noting that even during busy times, the wait is manageable. First-time visitors can expect a warm welcome and helpful guidance on flavor choices.

What to Order

The Pistachio gelato, priced at around $6.50 for a small cup, is a standout with its dense, nutty flavor and authentic Italian texture. Another must-try is the Stracciatella, available in a medium cup for approximately $8.50, which combines a sweet cream base with fine chocolate shards.

For those looking to explore more flavors, the Hazelnut and Mango options are popular choices. The Hazelnut offers a rich, Nutella-adjacent taste without being overly sweet, while the Mango sorbet provides a refreshing, dairy-free alternative. A full visit typically costs around $9–$10 for a medium cup with two flavors.

Who It's For

Della Nonna Gelato is ideal for those seeking a quick, high-quality dessert stop in Brooklyn. It's perfect for solo visits, casual dates, or families looking for a sweet treat after dinner. The shop's convenient location and reasonable prices make it accessible for both locals and visitors.

However, if you're looking for a sit-down dessert experience or extensive menu, this might not be the place for you. The focus is on quality gelato, not elaborate desserts. For those who prefer delivery, the shop's presence on Seamless and Grubhub offers a convenient option.

Getting There

The nearest subway access is the G train at Bedford–Nostrand Avs, about a 9- to 10-minute walk to Della Nonna Gelato. Alternatively, the J and Z trains at Kosciuszko Street are about 11–12 minutes away. The B43 bus also runs along Tompkins Avenue, with stops just a block from the shop.

Driving is an option, but parking can be challenging due to alternate-side regulations and limited street parking. It's often easier to rely on public transit or walk if you're already in the neighborhood. Street parking is available on nearby side streets like Madison or Putnam.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of Della Nonna Gelato, you'll find Peaches HotHouse, known for its Southern cuisine, just a few blocks south. Herbert von King Park, a popular green space, is about a ten-minute walk north, offering a perfect spot to enjoy your gelato.

The shop is a great addition to a day spent exploring Bedford-Stuyvesant. Visitors to the area for dining at local restaurants or enjoying the park will find Della Nonna Gelato a delightful stop for dessert. It's a neighborhood favorite that complements the local dining scene.

Best Time to Visit

For the best experience, visit Della Nonna Gelato on a weekday between 3:00 pm and 6:00 pm. This timing avoids the post-school rush and dinner crowds, allowing for a more relaxed visit. Late afternoons are ideal for sampling flavors without the pressure of a line.

Avoid visiting on hot summer weekends around 8:00–9:00 pm, when short lines are more common. The shop closes earlier on some weekdays, so plan accordingly. Checking their hours online before heading out is a smart move to ensure they're open.

The Reality Check

While Della Nonna Gelato is highly rated, some reviewers mention small portion sizes relative to the price. This is a common theme among dessert shops in Brooklyn, where quality often comes at a premium.

Additionally, inconsistent staffing hours can be a minor inconvenience. It's best to check their hours online before visiting to avoid disappointment. Those expecting a sit-down experience or extensive menu might leave unsatisfied, as the focus here is on artisanal gelato.

The Verdict

Della Nonna Gelato earned its City Hacked Gold Rating with a score of 90, reflecting its high-quality gelato and strong community presence. While it may not have national recognition, its local reputation is solid, with social media buzz and high ratings backing it up.

Visit for a taste of authentic Italian gelato in a neighborhood setting. It's perfect for a quick dessert stop, but not for those seeking a full-service dining experience. For a true gelato experience in Bed-Stuy, this is the place to be.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the hours for Della Nonna Gelato?
A: Della Nonna Gelato is open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11 AM to 9 PM, and Saturday from 7:30 PM to 12 AM.

Q: How much does a typical visit cost?
A: A typical visit costs around $9–$10 for a medium cup with two flavors.

Q: Is there seating available inside?
A: Seating is minimal, with a few stools available. Most customers take their gelato to go.

Q: What is the nearest subway station?
A: The nearest subway station is the G train at Bedford–Nostrand Avs, about a 9- to 10-minute walk away.

Q: Can I order Della Nonna Gelato for delivery?
A: Yes, Della Nonna Gelato is available for delivery through Seamless and Grubhub.