Overview

New Island is a family-owned Chinese takeout spot located at 27 Seguine Avenue in the Princes Bay neighborhood of Staten Island. Known for its straightforward approach, it caters primarily to locals seeking reliable Chinese fare without the frills. Operating seven days a week, it offers a menu full of familiar favorites at a price point that keeps it accessible, with most dishes landing in the $11 to $15 range.

The restaurant has been serving the community for over a decade, gaining a reputation for its staple dishes like General Tso's Chicken and Sesame Chicken. With a Google rating of 3.9 from 133 reviews and a Yelp rating of 3.7 from 22 reviews, it stands out for its consistency. Despite the mixed reviews, it maintains a loyal customer base that appreciates the generous portions and dependable service.

The Neighborhood

Princes Bay, located in Staten Island, is a predominantly residential area characterized by its low-density housing and limited commercial activity. New Island fits seamlessly into this setting, providing a convenient dining option for locals who prefer to stay within the neighborhood rather than venture to busier commercial hubs like Huguenot or Annadale.

Nearby, Amboy Road serves as a minor commercial artery where residents can find other local businesses and eateries. The area around New Island is frequented by residents running errands or returning from the nearby shoreline parks. The restaurant's location makes it a practical choice for those living south of Hylan Boulevard, especially families looking for a quick meal option.

The Vibe

New Island operates from a small storefront that prioritizes takeout and delivery over dine-in service. The interior is utilitarian, featuring a basic counter, minimal seating, and a menu board that emphasizes efficiency. The atmosphere is typical of a Staten Island takeout spot, with a focus on quick service and high turnover, especially during peak hours.

Service at New Island is straightforward, with staff accustomed to handling a steady stream of takeout orders. Regulars appreciate the no-nonsense approach, noting that the staff is efficient and the wait times are reasonable, typically ranging from 20 to 45 minutes for delivery. First-time visitors should expect a brisk, business-like interaction focused on getting orders out quickly.

What to Order

The General Tso's Chicken, priced at $14.25 for a large combination platter, is a standout. It features deep-fried chicken chunks in a sweet, garlicky sauce, served with broccoli. The Sesame Chicken, another favorite, offers a sweeter, stickier alternative, also priced at $14.25. Both dishes exemplify the classic American-Chinese takeout style that locals crave.

For those looking for variety, the menu includes Fried Wontons at $7.25 and Chicken Wings in the $8–$9 range. The cheapest item is plain white rice at about $3.00, while the most expensive are seafood dishes, reaching up to $22. A typical meal, including a combination platter and an appetizer, costs around $20–$25 per person.

Who It's For

New Island is ideal for neighborhood regulars seeking a quick, budget-friendly meal. It's perfect for solo lunches, family dinners, or anyone craving Chinese takeout without the hassle of traveling far. Its straightforward menu and reliable service make it a go-to for locals.

However, those seeking a dine-in experience or culinary adventure should look elsewhere. The restaurant's focus on takeout and delivery means it's better suited for convenience than ambiance. While it doesn't appear on major delivery apps, its own online ordering system is efficient for those nearby.

Getting There

The nearest rail transit is the Staten Island Railway, with the Princes Bay station just northwest of New Island. It's a short 6–8 minute walk southeast from the station to the restaurant. Local buses on Amboy Road and Hylan Boulevard also serve the area, providing additional access for those coming from other parts of Staten Island.

Driving is a viable option, with on-street parking typically available on Seguine Avenue. The low-density nature of the neighborhood means parking is less of a hassle compared to more congested areas of NYC. However, given the convenience of the railway and bus routes, many locals opt for public transit.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of New Island, visitors can explore the shoreline parks along Raritan Bay, offering scenic views and outdoor activities. Amboy Road, a short walk north, provides additional dining and shopping options, making it a convenient stop for locals running errands or enjoying a day out.

For those visiting the area for its natural beauty, New Island serves as a practical dining option. It caters to residents and visitors alike who are in the neighborhood for its parks and recreational spaces, providing a reliable meal option after a day of outdoor activities.

Best Time to Visit

For the best experience, visit New Island during weekday afternoons when the rush is minimal, and service is swift. This timing ensures that you can enjoy your meal without the peak hour wait times that typically occur during dinner hours.

Avoid visiting on Friday and Saturday evenings when the kitchen is busiest, and delivery times can extend. The restaurant's hours, closing at 10:30 PM on Saturdays, mean late-night cravings might need to be satisfied elsewhere.

The Reality Check

One common complaint among reviewers is the inconsistency in delivery times, with some noting delays during peak hours. While this is typical for busy takeout spots, it's worth considering if you're on a tight schedule.

Additionally, some diners have mentioned that the flavor can be hit or miss, with certain dishes lacking the expected punch. Those seeking a more refined dining experience might find New Island's straightforward approach lacking in complexity.

The Verdict

New Island's City Hacked Gold Rating of 78 reflects its role as a reliable, value-focused neighborhood staple. While it may not attract the attention of major food critics, its consistent quality and generous portions make it a favorite among locals.

For those in Princes Bay, it's a convenient choice for quick Chinese takeout. However, if you're looking for a dining destination with ambiance and flair, this might not be the place for you. New Island is the go-to for when you need a no-fuss meal that hits the spot.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How do I get to New Island by public transit?
A: The closest station is Princes Bay on the Staten Island Railway, about a 6–8 minute walk.

Q: Is there parking available near New Island?
A: Yes, on-street parking is typically available on Seguine Avenue.

Q: What is the price range for meals at New Island?
A: Most combination platters range from $11.95 to $14.95, with a typical meal costing $20–$25 per person.

Q: Can I make a reservation at New Island?
A: No, New Island operates on a walk-in and call/online order basis only.

Q: Does New Island offer delivery through third-party apps?
A: No, delivery is handled through their own online ordering system, not third-party apps.