Overview

Pugsley Pizza, located at 590 E 191st St in the Bronx's Belmont neighborhood, has been a staple for Fordham University students and locals since 1984. This family-run pizzeria is known for its late-night hours, staying open until 3:00 a.m., making it a go-to spot for night owls and those seeking a classic New York slice. The menu is straightforward, offering authentic Italian pizzas at an affordable price point, with a large cheese pie costing around $16–$18.

The food quality at Pugsley Pizza is consistently praised, particularly the chicken roll and the classic cheese slice. With a Google rating of 4.6 from 694 reviews and a Yelp rating of 4.4 from 219 reviews, the pizzeria stands out for its taste and tradition. It’s more than just a pizza joint; it’s a Fordham institution, cherished for its long-standing reputation and engaging, interactive atmosphere.

The Neighborhood

Belmont, known as the Bronx's Little Italy, is a vibrant neighborhood where Italian heritage is evident in the local businesses and eateries. Pugsley Pizza fits seamlessly into this community, serving as a beloved spot for students and locals alike. The area is bustling with activity, thanks to its proximity to Fordham University and the cultural richness of Arthur Avenue.

Just a short walk from Pugsley Pizza, you'll find the Bronx Zoo and the New York Botanical Garden, two major attractions that draw visitors year-round. The foot traffic in the area is a mix of students, tourists, and locals, creating a lively atmosphere. The streets are filled with people looking to enjoy the neighborhood's culinary offerings and cultural landmarks.

The Vibe

Pugsley Pizza operates as a counter-service slice shop with a cozy, slightly chaotic dining room. The walls are adorned with handmade signs and student memorabilia, giving it a homey feel. It's a walk-in only establishment, with no reservations needed, and it tends to get noisy, especially during late-night hours when students flock in after a night out.

Service at Pugsley Pizza is engaging and interactive, with a tradition of “hitting the gong” adding to the lively atmosphere. Regulars appreciate the friendly and efficient service, while newcomers are often drawn in by the energetic environment. The staff is known for their quick service, ensuring that even during busy times, customers are not left waiting long.

What to Order

The standout menu item at Pugsley Pizza is the classic Cheese Pizza, priced at $16–$18 for a large pie. The thin crust, well-browned cheese, and perfectly balanced sauce make it a favorite among regulars. Another must-try is the Chicken Roll, which costs around $7–$9 and is filled with chopped chicken, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.

For those looking for variety, the Pepperoni Pizza is a popular choice, with a large pie costing $18–$20. The Grandma Pizza, priced in the mid-$20s, offers a thicker crust and a rich tomato flavor. Budget-conscious diners can enjoy a garlic knot for $1–$2, while a full meal with two slices and a drink typically costs $10–$15.

Who It's For

Pugsley Pizza is ideal for students, late-night snackers, and anyone seeking a budget-friendly meal. Its proximity to Fordham University makes it a popular choice for students looking for a quick bite between classes or after a night out. The late hours cater to night owls and those working late shifts.

However, if you're looking for a quiet, sit-down dining experience, Pugsley Pizza might not be the best choice. The lively atmosphere and student crowd can be overwhelming for those seeking a more relaxed meal. For those who prefer to dine at home, delivery is available through Uber Eats and Slice, providing a convenient option.

Getting There

To reach Pugsley Pizza by subway, take the B or D line to the Fordham Road station. From there, it's a 10–12 minute walk east along East Fordham Road, followed by a short block south to East 191st Street. Several bus routes also serve the area, stopping within a 2–3 minute walk of the pizzeria.

Driving to Pugsley Pizza can be challenging due to limited street parking and the busy nature of the area. Metered spots are available, but they fill up quickly, especially during peak hours. Alternate side parking rules apply, so public transit is often the more convenient option for visiting this bustling neighborhood.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of Pugsley Pizza are the Bronx Zoo and the New York Botanical Garden, both major attractions that draw visitors from all over. These landmarks are just a short walk from the pizzeria, making it an ideal stop for those exploring the area.

Pugsley Pizza is a great addition to any visit to Belmont's Little Italy. Whether you're visiting the zoo, the botanical garden, or simply exploring the neighborhood's Italian eateries, a stop at Pugsley Pizza offers a taste of local tradition and a break from sightseeing.

Best Time to Visit

For the best experience at Pugsley Pizza, visit between 3:00–5:00 p.m. on weekdays. This window avoids the lunch rush and the evening student wave, ensuring faster service and easier access to tables. The atmosphere is more relaxed during these hours, making it a perfect time for a leisurely meal.

Avoid visiting late at night on weekends, as the pizzeria becomes crowded with students and bar-goers. The busiest times are typically around midnight, when the lines are longest and the wait times increase. Despite the late-night hours, it's best to plan your visit earlier in the day for a more pleasant experience.

The Reality Check

While Pugsley Pizza enjoys a strong reputation, it's not a place for those seeking a quiet meal. The lively atmosphere and student crowd can be overwhelming, especially during peak times. Reviewers note that the noise level can be high, making it difficult for conversation.

For diners expecting a refined dining experience, Pugsley Pizza may disappoint. It's a casual, counter-service spot with a focus on quick, tasty slices rather than ambiance. Those who prefer a more polished setting might find the informal nature of the pizzeria less appealing.

The Verdict

Pugsley Pizza earned its City Hacked Gold Rating with a score of 84, reflecting its status as a beloved local institution. Its long-standing presence in the community, combined with consistently high ratings, makes it a reliable choice for pizza lovers. The score indicates a place that delivers on taste and tradition, even if it lacks some refinements.

For those seeking a slice of Bronx history and a taste of authentic New York pizza, Pugsley Pizza is a must-visit. It's perfect for a casual meal with friends or a late-night snack. However, if you're looking for a quiet dinner, consider other options. Pugsley Pizza is where tradition meets taste.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the hours of operation for Pugsley Pizza?
A: Pugsley Pizza is open Monday–Saturday from 11:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m. and Sunday from 2:00 p.m. to 3:00 a.m.

Q: How can I get to Pugsley Pizza using public transit?
A: Take the B or D subway lines to Fordham Road station, then walk 10–12 minutes east.

Q: Is there parking available near Pugsley Pizza?
A: Street parking is limited, with metered spots available. Public transit is recommended due to parking constraints.

Q: Can I order delivery from Pugsley Pizza?
A: Yes, Pugsley Pizza offers delivery through Uber Eats and Slice.

Q: What is the price range for a meal at Pugsley Pizza?
A: A typical meal, such as two slices and a drink, costs around $10–$15 before tax and tip.