Overview

Sweet Polly is a cocktail bar located at 71 6th Ave in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn. This venue caters to locals seeking a sophisticated drink spot before or after events at the nearby Barclays Center. Founded by Murat Uyaroglu, the owner of the Hungry Ghost coffee chain, Sweet Polly opened in 2017 as a cocktail-focused venue. The bar is known for its dim lighting and intimate atmosphere, making it a popular choice for date nights and small gatherings. The price range is moderate, with cocktails typically priced between $16 and $18.

The quality of drinks at Sweet Polly is a major draw, with reviewers frequently praising the well-crafted cocktails and impressive presentation. The venue holds a Google rating of 4.5 based on 428 reviews, and a Yelp rating of 4.2 from 219 reviews. The bar's signature drink, the Polly 75, is a standout, offering a unique twist on the classic French 75. Sweet Polly distinguishes itself from other bars in the area with its focus on high-quality cocktails and a relaxed, intimate setting.

The Neighborhood

Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, is known for its diverse community and vibrant cultural scene. Sweet Polly fits seamlessly into this neighborhood, attracting both residents and visitors attending events at the nearby Barclays Center. The area is characterized by a mix of historic brownstones and modern developments, with a lively arts and dining scene.

Located just two blocks north of the Barclays Center, Sweet Polly benefits from significant foot traffic, especially on event nights. The nearby Atlantic Terminal Mall and several Hungry Ghost coffee locations add to the bustling atmosphere. The bar draws a crowd of professionals and couples looking for a quieter, more refined experience than the typical sports bar.

The Vibe

Sweet Polly offers a lively yet manageable atmosphere, with a well-judged noise level that allows for conversation. The bar features a spacious layout with circular, candlelit tables that enhance the intimate setting. Music is kept at a background level, primarily consisting of recorded playlists, which complements the venue's focus on conversation and cocktails.

Service at Sweet Polly is generally friendly and attentive, though some reviewers note slower service during peak hours. The staff is known for being responsive and accommodating, contributing to a positive overall experience. First-time visitors can expect a warm welcome and a focus on quality service, despite occasional delays during busy times.

What to Drink

The Polly 75, a riff on the classic French 75, is a must-try at Sweet Polly. Priced around $16–$17, this cocktail combines gin, lemon, and sparkling wine for a refreshing and well-balanced drink. The presentation is impressive, with a focus on quality ingredients and a sophisticated aesthetic.

In addition to the Polly 75, Sweet Polly's menu features a range of house cocktails, spirit-forward classics, and small plates. The oyster happy hour offers excellent value, with prices typically between $3 and $4 per oyster. For those looking for a more affordable option, the bar also serves New York beers and Old World wines, with prices ranging from $8 to $15 per glass.

Who It's For

Sweet Polly is ideal for couples and small groups seeking a refined cocktail experience in Prospect Heights. The intimate setting and high-quality drinks make it a perfect spot for date nights or pre- and post-event gatherings at Barclays Center.

However, those looking for a lively nightlife scene or a sports bar atmosphere may want to look elsewhere. The focus here is on quality cocktails and conversation, not on loud music or large crowds. If you're seeking a sophisticated drink in a relaxed setting, Sweet Polly is the place to be.

Getting There

Sweet Polly is easily accessible via public transit, with the Atlantic Avenue–Barclays Center subway station just a 5-minute walk away. This major transit hub is served by the 2, 3, 4, 5, B, D, N, Q, and R lines. The Bergen Street 2/3 station is even closer, requiring only a 3-minute walk to reach the bar.

For those driving, street parking can be challenging, especially during events at Barclays Center. Metered spots are available on Flatbush Avenue, while unmetered residential spaces can be found on 6th Avenue and nearby side streets. Given the transit options, driving may not be the most convenient choice.

Nearby Attractions

Sweet Polly is located near several notable landmarks, including the Barclays Center and Atlantic Terminal Mall. These attractions draw significant foot traffic, particularly on event nights, making the area lively and dynamic.

Visitors to Prospect Heights can easily incorporate a stop at Sweet Polly into their plans. Whether attending a concert or game at Barclays Center or exploring the local dining scene, this cocktail bar offers a sophisticated and welcoming environment for a drink.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit Sweet Polly is during weekday happy hours from 4 to 6 p.m. This time offers excellent value on drinks and a more relaxed atmosphere, making it ideal for those looking to unwind after work or enjoy a quieter evening.

On weekends, the bar tends to be busier, especially before and after events at Barclays Center. To avoid long waits and crowded conditions, it's best to arrive early or consider visiting on a weekday instead.

The Reality Check

The most common complaint about Sweet Polly is overcrowding during peak times, particularly on weekends. Reviewers note that the bar can become quite packed, making it difficult to move around and order drinks promptly.

Additionally, some patrons have mentioned issues with slow service during busy periods. While the staff is generally friendly and attentive, they may struggle to keep up with demand during peak hours, leading to longer wait times for drinks and seating.

The Verdict

Sweet Polly's City Hacked Rating of Platinum, with a score of 86, reflects its reputation as a top-tier cocktail bar in Prospect Heights. The venue's focus on high-quality drinks and a sophisticated atmosphere has earned it recognition in local and niche outlets, making it a standout choice for those seeking a refined experience.

For those who appreciate well-crafted cocktails and a relaxed setting, Sweet Polly is a must-visit. However, if you prefer a more energetic nightlife scene or are averse to crowded spaces, you might want to explore other options. Sweet Polly delivers an intimate cocktail experience that is hard to match.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the nearest subway station to Sweet Polly?
A: The nearest subway station is Atlantic Avenue–Barclays Center, served by multiple lines, about a 5-minute walk away.

Q: Does Sweet Polly have a cover charge?
A: No, Sweet Polly does not have a cover charge. Entry is free, with spending based on drinks and food.

Q: What are Sweet Polly's happy hour times?
A: Happy hour at Sweet Polly runs from 4 to 6 p.m. on weekdays, offering discounted drinks.

Q: Is there parking available near Sweet Polly?
A: Street parking is available but limited, especially during events at Barclays Center. Consider public transit for convenience.

Q: What is the typical dress code at Sweet Polly?
A: Sweet Polly maintains a standard bar dress code, with no formal requirements or doorman scene.