Overview

Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen, located at 793 Grand St in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a dessert bakery that caters to those with a sweet tooth. Opened in 2022 by Melissa Johnson, a seasoned baker with a decade of experience, this bakery specializes in American-style celebration desserts. With a focus on pre-orders and pickups, it serves locals looking for nostalgic flavors in their desserts. The bakery's offerings include cupcakes, banana pudding, and cheesecakes, all crafted with a nod to classic American treats.

The bakery has earned a stellar reputation, boasting a 5-star rating on Google with 91 reviews and a 4.8 rating on Yelp from 15 reviews. Customers rave about the dense, frosting-heavy cupcakes and the shareable banana pudding trays. What sets Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen apart is its commitment to quality and the unique flavors like Fruity Pebbles and Cinnamon Toast Crunch. This is not just another bakery; it's a place where desserts are crafted with care and a touch of nostalgia, making it a standout in the area.

The Neighborhood

Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is known for its mix of old and new, with legacy neighborhood retail sitting alongside innovative food businesses. Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen fits right into this eclectic mix, offering a sweet escape for locals and visitors alike. The area is home to a diverse community, with young professionals, artists, and long-time residents coexisting in this vibrant neighborhood.

Nearby, you'll find the Grand Street L train corridor, a hub of activity with a mix of small bars, restaurants, and shops. Cooper Park is just a short walk away, offering a green space for relaxation. The bakery is situated in a quieter part of Grand Street, making it a perfect spot for those seeking a sweet treat away from the hustle and bustle.

The Vibe

Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen operates more like a dessert studio than a traditional bakery. With limited retail hours and a focus on pre-orders, the space is compact, emphasizing production over seating. Customers typically place orders online and pick them up during designated hours, ensuring a smooth and efficient experience.

The staff at Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen is known for their friendly and accommodating service. Regulars appreciate the personal touch, with many noting the ease of communication for custom orders. First-time visitors can expect a straightforward process, with clear instructions for ordering and pickup, making the experience hassle-free.

What to Order

The standout menu items at Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen include the 6 pack Cupcakes ($28.00) and the Banana Pudding Drop ($20.00). The cupcakes are dense and frosting-heavy, with flavors like Bday Sprinkles and Strawberry Crunch offering a nostalgic twist. The Banana Pudding Drop is a shareable tray, perfect for gatherings, with a creamy texture and rich banana flavor.

For those looking to explore more, the Strawberry Cheesecake ($27.00) is a must-try, offering a full cheesecake experience rather than just a slice. The 12 Pack Cupcakes ($55.00) caters to larger events, featuring the same delightful flavors in bulk. With items ranging from $20.00 to $55.00, customers can expect to spend around $10–$15 per person when sharing desserts.

Who It's For

Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen is ideal for those planning a gathering or looking to satisfy a sweet craving with friends. Its focus on pre-orders makes it perfect for parties and events, where desserts are a centerpiece. The bakery's unique flavors and quality make it a go-to for locals seeking something special.

However, if you're looking for a sit-down dessert experience or a late-night snack, this might not be the place for you. With no seating and limited hours, it's best suited for those who plan ahead. Delivery isn't a primary focus, so spontaneous visitors might leave disappointed.

Getting There

The easiest way to reach Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen is via the L train, with the Grand Street station just a 6–7 minute walk away. For those relying on buses, the B43 and B60 routes are nearby, providing convenient access to the bakery.

Driving in Williamsburg can be challenging, with street parking being the norm. Alternate side parking rules apply, so it's wise to check signage. Given the ease of public transit, it's often more convenient to leave the car at home and enjoy a stroll through the neighborhood.

Nearby Attractions

Within walking distance of Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen, you'll find Cooper Park, a green oasis perfect for a post-dessert stroll. The Grand Street station offers easy access to other parts of Brooklyn, making it a convenient stop for those exploring the area.

For those visiting Williamsburg for its vibrant art scene or eclectic shops, Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen provides a sweet addition to the itinerary. Whether you're heading to a gallery or shopping along Graham Avenue, this bakery offers a delightful pause in your day.

Best Time to Visit

The best time to visit Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen is mid-afternoon on weekdays, particularly Wednesday or Thursday. This timing allows you to avoid the weekend rush and ensures a wider selection of desserts. Pre-ordering online is recommended to secure your favorites.

Avoid visiting on weekends after 4 pm, as the bakery gets busy with locals picking up orders for gatherings. With limited hours, it's essential to plan your visit to ensure you get the full Yummy Tummy’s experience.

The Reality Check

The most common complaint about Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen is its limited hours, which can be inconvenient for spontaneous visits. Some reviewers mention the lack of seating as a downside, as it limits the ability to enjoy treats on-site.

Additionally, those expecting a traditional bakery experience with a wide array of ready-to-eat options might be disappointed. The focus on pre-orders and pickups means that walk-in availability is limited, making it less suitable for last-minute dessert cravings.

The Verdict

Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen earned its City Hacked Rating of Gold with a score of 87, reflecting its quality desserts and strong community presence. While not a citywide destination, it excels as a neighborhood favorite, offering unique flavors and a personal touch.

For those planning an event or seeking a special treat, Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen is a worthwhile stop. However, if you're looking for a casual dessert spot with seating, this might not be the best fit. Pre-order for the best experience and savor the nostalgia.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the hours for Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen?
A: The bakery is open Wednesday to Saturday from 2–8 PM and Sunday from 1–6:30 PM.

Q: How can I get to Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen by subway?
A: Take the L train to Grand Street station, then walk east for about 6–7 minutes.

Q: Is there parking available near Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen?
A: Street parking is available, but be mindful of alternate side parking rules.

Q: Can I walk in and order without a reservation?
A: It's best to pre-order online, as walk-in availability is limited.

Q: What is the price range for desserts at Yummy Tummy’s Kitchen?
A: Prices range from $20.00 for a Banana Pudding Drop to $55.00 for a 12 Pack Cupcakes.